Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Personal tools



Braun, Kerstin (2013). Giving victims a voice: On the problems of introducing victim impact statements in German criminal procedure. German Law Journal. 14(9): 1819-1908.

Over the course of the last decade, however, scholars, including Wemmers, have started to address the absence of VIS schemes in inquisitorial criminal justice systems and begun to contemplate whether they could be beneficial to victims in these systems.9 In the context of Germany's inquisitorial system, Marlene Hanloser has suggested the introduction of VIS schemes in criminal trials in order to grant all victims the right to be heard by making statements on how the crime has affected them.10 Against the backdrop of this scholarly debate, this paper analyzes whether and for whom the introduction of VIS schemes in Germany could be valuable. In assessing the suitability of VIS schemes in the German context, this paper focuses on the alleged benefits for victims and the potential risks for defendants' rights. The remainder of this paper is structured into four parts. Part B analyzes how VIS schemes operate in Australian jurisdictions. This part subsequently considers the possibilities for victim participation in the structures of the adversarial criminal justice system in general and contends that victim participation in adversarial systems without the violation of defendants' rights is possible only to a limited extent. Part C determines that the structure of the German inquisitorial system generally permits victim participation at trial to a greater extent than the structure of the adversarial system. This part subsequently identifies that while some victims have been granted ample opportunities to present views and concerns in German criminal trials, other victims have no explicit right to do so. These victims could potentially benefit from the introduction of VIS schemes enabling them to present information to the court about how the crime has affected them if they so desire. (excerpt)

Restorative Justice Online - Featured Video

Restorative Justice Library Search

Search 11427 publications on restorative justice